One Shot or Two? Necessity of COVID-19 Vaccination Among People Living with HIV and/or Chronic Liver Disease

At the time of this writing, the United States’ Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has provided Emergency Use Authorizations (EUAs) to 3 COVID-19 vaccines, with Novavax’s product potentially leading the race to become the fourth. While some have fretted over “which vaccine” is “the best”, governors and clinicians have resoundingly adopted a simple answer: “which ever vaccine you can get”. While President Biden has pushed to expand eligibility to all adults in the US by May 1st, as we’re all too familiar with in patient advocacy, eligibility does not necessarily equate to access and, in this respect, demand still vastly outstrips vaccine supply domestically.

The debate on who should get a vaccine and when began well before the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) issued interim recommendations in December 2020. ACIP’s recommendations focused primarily on constructing an ethical model based on hospitalizations and mortality, with an eye toward those performing duties most necessary to meet the health care demands of the moment. Ultimately, outside of this job-based prioritization, ACIP gave top priority via age-based allocation and then ascertaining those at-risk for these outcomes based on pre-existing conditions. Most states adopted some version of these prioritized populations. The debate on the efficacy of this model continues to rage on – what about those in marginalized communities more impacted by COVID-19 than more affluent communities? What about younger people with comorbidities? Which health conditions should be prioritized?

Regardless of where one’s local government falls on this debate, evidence catalogued by the CDC indicates a very real need for people living with HIV and those with chronic liver diseases to seek a vaccine as readily as possible as these cohorts are at increased risk for complications related to a COVID-19 infection. Studies have found PLWH experiencing an acute COVID-19 infection may see as much as 50% drop in CD4 T-cells compared to their historical levels, a condition known as lymphopenia – of which, is also an indicator for severe COVID-19 and protracted recovery or death. Additionally, the same study found key clinical metrics used to measure inflammation were similarly increased among PLWH. Another study out of Wuhan, examining people with chronic, yet controlled Hepatitis B infections may see a reactivation of viral activity and/or potentially face significant progression of liver cirrhosis during and after a COVID-19 diagnosis. Another study found SARS-CoV-2 may target certain cells in the bile tract and cause focused damage to the systems serving a person’s liver, with another study suggesting the need for health care providers to emphasize liver repair post COVID diagnosis.

While Janssen ensured PLWH were enrolled in phase 3 clinical trials for their product, none of the currently authorized products included solid organ transplant recipients in their trials. While the American Society of Transplantation notes COVID-19 vaccine administration recommendations for solid organ transplant recipients remains the same as other vaccines (either completed at least 2 weeks prior to transplant or initiated at least 1 month after transplant). Which may pose a problem according to a study published in March showing transplant recipients having received the first shot in the series mounted an antibody response just 17% of the time. While antibody responses are not necessary to confer immunity, they are the leading indication of an immune response. The authors of this study will be seeking to answer that question later this year.

Furthermore, additional research is needed in assessing post-acute COVID-19 infections and the implications of “long COVID”. Most research at this moment on long-COVID is tied to assessing symptom presentation and frequency of health care needs. However, there is a minor bit of information regarding organ function post-hospitalization with COVID-19 – none of it is “good news”. In particular, people experiencing chronic liver diseases were almost 2 times as likely to experience “major adverse events” after being released from the hospital due to COVID-19.

All of this information culminates with a sense of urgency some states are heeding in expanding vaccine access “ahead of schedule” to include people living with HIV or specific programming targeted to provide vaccines to these communities.

Brandon Macsata, CEO of ADAP Advocacy Association, recently penned a blog addressing any hesitancy among people living with HIV around getting their vaccines: “Vaccines are an important element of the journey, along with proven public health strategies (i.e., wearing masks, remaining social distant, washing hands). For the HIV-positive community, it is even more important for us to do our collective part to protect ourselves, as well as the people around us. Get your Covid-19 vaccine!

With the CDC’s guidance on prioritizing our communities in vaccination schemes, I couldn’t agree more.

Jen Laws, President & CEO

Jen Laws (Pronouns: He/Him/His) is the President & Founder of Policy Candy, LLC, which is a non-partisan health policy analysis firm specializing in various aspects of health care and public health policy, focusing on the needs of the HIV-affected and Transgender communities. In that capacity, Jen has served as the President & CEO of the Community Access National Network (CANN), beginning in January 2022. He previously served as the Project Director of CANN's HIV/HCV Co-Infection Watch, as well as 340B Policy Consultant.

Jen began his advocacy efforts in Philadelphia in 2005, at the age of 19, coordinating team efforts for a corporation participating in the AIDS Walk. His connection to HIV advocacy grew when partnering with Mr. Friendly, a leading anti-HIV-stigma campaign.

He began working in public health policy in 2013, as a subcontractor for Broward Regional Planning Council evaluating Marketplace plans for plan year 2014, advising and educating constituents on plan selection. Jen was a member of South Florida AIDS Network and has worked with Florida Department of Health, Broward and Miami-Dade County Health Departments, Pride Center South Florida, and other local organizations to South Florida in addressing the concerns and needs of these intersecting communities. During this time, Jen was seated on the board of directors for the ADAP Advocacy Association.

Having moved to the New Orleans area in 2019, Jen resumed his community-based advocacy as the chair of Louisiana's Ending the HIV Epidemic planning subcommittee for Data-based Policy and Advocacy, regular participation as a community member and "do-gooder" with other governmental and non-governmental planning bodies across the Louisiana, and engages with other southern state planning bodies. He continues his advocacy in governmental health care policy evaluation, which has been utilized to expand access to quality healthcare by working with RAD Remedy to deliver the nation's foremost database of trans* competent health care providers. Lending his expertise on policy matters ranging from 340B impact on RW providers and patients to strategic communications and data analysis, Jen's approach to community engagement is focused on being accessible across all stakeholder groups and centering the perspectives of PLWHA and Transgender people. He is a community ambassador alumni of the CDC's Let's Stop HIV Together campaign.

In his personal life, Jen enjoys spending his time being "ridiculously wholesome" with his partner, Aisha, and her two amazing daughters. In their personal time, when not immersed in crafts or house projects, they can be found seeking opportunities to help their neighbors, friends, and community members (who have come to rightfully expect exquisite gift baskets of Aisha's homemade jams and jellies from time to time). Jen strives to set a good example both in his personal professional life of integrating values into action and extending the kindness and care that have led him to a life he calls "extraordinarily lucky".

https://tiicann.org
Previous
Previous

The Most Meaningful Public Health Intervention: Housing

Next
Next

Novel Developments: Merck & Gilead Partner on New ARVs