Alcohol Use Does Not Harm DAA Efficacy, Yet Payer Barriers Persist

In healthcare, the interplay between perceptions and policies can sometimes adversely affect the very individuals they intend to benefit. One such area of contention is the perceived impact of alcohol use on the effectiveness of treatments for hepatitis C Virus (HCV). A recent study, published in JAMA Network Open and spotlighted by MedPage Today, led by Christopher T. Rentsch, PhD, and co-authored by Emily J. Cartwright, MD, explored this relationship. Their findings were clear: alcohol use and alcohol use disorder (AUD) did not diminish the odds of achieving a sustained virologic response with Direct-Acting Antiviral (DAA) therapy for chronic HCV infection.

Yet, despite such evidence, certain clinicians still hesitate or even refuse to administer HCV therapy to patients who consume alcohol. Furthermore, some payers mandate alcohol abstinence as a precondition for reimbursing DAA therapy for HCV. This stance becomes even more alarming in light of the Center for Disease Control & Prevention's (CDC) recent data, which shows a staggering 129% surge in reported cases of acute hepatitis C since 2014. It's imperative that we prioritize evidence over misconceptions, especially when lives are at stake.

The NIH's Perspective

A study supported by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) echoes these findings, revealing that individuals with alcohol use disorder (AUD) are less likely to receive antiviral treatments for hepatitis C. Despite current guidelines recommending such treatment irrespective of alcohol use, the study, led by scientists at Yale University, found that those with AUD, even if they were currently abstinent, were less likely to receive curative DAA treatment for hepatitis C within one or three years of diagnosis compared to those without AUD. This treatment gap, attributed to stigma around substance use and concerns about treatment adherence, underscores the need to address these disparities, especially among those with AUD.

The Case for Change

The implications of these studies are clear: policies need revision. Evidence-based policies in healthcare are paramount. Denying HCV patients access to DAA therapy based on their alcohol consumption habits is not only unwarranted but also counterproductive. As the study's authors have highlighted, such restrictions could pose unnecessary barriers for patients and hinder efforts to eliminate HCV.

Both state-specific policies and national guidelines, like those from The American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases (AASLD), need to evolve in light of these findings. Healthcare providers, policymakers, and advocacy groups have a pivotal role in driving this change, ensuring that all HCV patients, irrespective of their alcohol consumption habits, have access to the best possible care.

Charting a Path Forward

The revelations from these studies underscore more than just the need for policy adjustments; they challenge our collective commitment to championing evidence-based healthcare. In an era where misinformation can easily cloud judgment, it's crucial that treatments for HCV are not just theoretically available but are genuinely accessible to all, regardless of their alcohol consumption habits.

The findings from both the NIH and JAMA studies don't merely point out gaps; they expose deep-rooted systemic issues. Current policies have not adequately addressed the needs of HCV patients, and there's a pressing need for more inclusive guidelines.

To transform this call to action into tangible progress, we must:

  • Reassess and Revise Existing Policies: Ensure that guidelines, especially those from influential bodies like AASLD, are updated in line with the latest scientific evidence, removing any unwarranted barriers related to alcohol consumption. As demonstrated by the efficacy of the Center for Health Law and Policy Innovation’s (CHLPI) work in assessing and breaking down barriers to curative DAAs in Medicaid programs, further work must be done to break these payer-based barriers to care in private and employer sponsored plans.

  • Strengthen Advocacy and Awareness: Engage with healthcare providers, policymakers, and patients to spread awareness about the non-impact of alcohol on DAA therapy's efficacy, countering prevailing misconceptions.

  • Promote Continuous Research and Dialogue: Encourage further studies and maintain an open dialogue with all stakeholders to continuously refine our understanding and approach to HCV treatment.

The conclusions drawn from these studies underscore the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead of us. As the research emphatically states, alcohol consumption should not be a barrier to HCV treatment. Such restrictions are discriminatory in nature and threaten efforts in the fight to eliminate HCV. With evidence-based policy decisions and unwavering dedication, we can eliminate the barriers and ensure access to curative HCV treatment.

Travis Manint - Communications Consultant

Travis Manint is a Healthcare Policy Communication Strategist who bridges the gap between complex healthcare policies and clear, actionable communication. With over 15 years of marketing experience and a growing passion for healthcare advocacy, Travis brings a unique perspective to the challenges facing people living with HIV and viral hepatitis.

As Strategic Communications Director at CANN, Travis analyzes healthcare policy developments and translates their implications for diverse stakeholders across the healthcare ecosystem. His work focuses on making intricate policy issues accessible and actionable, particularly in areas of medication access, healthcare affordability, and health equity. He is a regular contributor to HIV-HCV Watch and has been published in Positively Aware.

Beyond his role at CANN, Travis serves as Executive Director of One Way Love, Inc., a nonprofit addressing housing and food insecurity for at-risk youth. His commitment to community advocacy is driven by personal experiences with HIV and substance use disorder, informing his approach to healthcare policy analysis and communication.

Travis emphasizes the importance of addressing healthcare disparities, particularly among LGBTQIA+ communities, people of color, and other marginalized populations. His work consistently highlights the intersection of policy decisions with real-world impacts on patient care and access.

Through his strategic communication expertise and dedication to advocacy, Travis works to foster a more equitable, efficient, and patient-centered healthcare system. His goal is to empower stakeholders with the knowledge and tools they need to drive meaningful change in healthcare policy and delivery.

Previous
Previous

Upper-Payment Limits; Drug "Affordability" Boards Risk Medication Access

Next
Next

Unveiling Disparities: OIG Report on HIV Care in Medicaid